Vitalik Buterin: Ethereum protocol development needs to introduce simplification and "garbage collection" features to avoid bloating

ETH-3,16%

PANews January 18th News, Vitalik Buterin posted on X platform stating, "An important and long underestimated aspect of ‘trustlessness,’ ‘leaving the test,’ and ‘self-sovereignty’ is protocol simplicity.
Even if a protocol has hundreds of thousands of nodes, possesses 49% Byzantine fault tolerance, and nodes verify everything through quantum-resistant Pederas and Starks, but if the protocol is a massive chaos composed of hundreds of thousands of lines of code and five types of doctoral-level cryptography, then this protocol will ultimately fail in all three tests:
It is not trustless because users must trust a small subset of high-level officials to inform the protocol’s properties.
It cannot pass the ‘leave test’ because if the existing client team leaves, it is extremely difficult for a new team to reach the same quality level.
It does not have self-sovereignty because even the most technically capable people cannot check and understand it; it does not fully belong to the users.
At the same time, its security is also relatively low because each part of the protocol, especially when it interacts with other parts in complex ways, carries the risk of protocol collapse.
One concern I have about Ethereum protocol development is that we may be too eager to add new features to meet highly specific needs, even if these features make the protocol bloated or introduce entirely new types of interaction components or complex cryptography as key dependencies.
This may be beneficial for short-term feature gains but is highly destructive to maintaining long-term self-sovereignty and creating a centennial decentralized superstructure that transcends empire and ideological rise and fall.
The core issue is that if we judge protocol changes from the perspective of ‘how much they alter the existing protocol,’ then the desire to maintain backward compatibility means that the number of additions far exceeds the number of reductions, inevitably leading to protocol bloating over time.
To address this, Ethereum development needs a clear ‘simplification’ or ‘garbage collection’ function. ‘Simplification’ has three criteria:

  1. Minimize the total lines of code of the protocol.
  2. Avoid unnecessary dependencies on fundamentally complex technical components.
  3. Increase more invariants: core properties that the protocol can rely on, such as EIP-6780 (removing selfdestruct), which limits each block to changing at most N storage slots, greatly simplifying client development.
    Garbage collection can be scattered or large-scale. The scattered approach attempts to simplify existing features, making them more concise and reasonable. An example of large-scale garbage collection is replacing PoW with PoS.
    Another approach is ‘Rosetta-style backward compatibility,’ where complex but rarely used features remain available but are ‘downgraded’ to smart contract code rather than being part of the mandatory protocol, so new client developers do not have to handle them.
    For example, after upgrading to fully native account abstraction, all old transaction types can be phased out; existing precompiles can be replaced with EVM or RISC-V code; ultimately, the virtual machine can be changed from EVM to RISC-V.
    Finally, it is hoped that client developers will no longer need to handle all old versions of the Ethereum protocol. In the long run, Ethereum’s rate of change should slow down, and efforts should be made to prevent those useless parts from becoming a permanent burden on the Ethereum protocol.
View Original
Disclaimer: The information on this page may come from third parties and does not represent the views or opinions of Gate. The content displayed on this page is for reference only and does not constitute any financial, investment, or legal advice. Gate does not guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information and shall not be liable for any losses arising from the use of this information. Virtual asset investments carry high risks and are subject to significant price volatility. You may lose all of your invested principal. Please fully understand the relevant risks and make prudent decisions based on your own financial situation and risk tolerance. For details, please refer to Disclaimer.

Related Articles

Mysterious Whale Withdraws $4.29M USDT from Aave to Purchase 2,012 ETH

Gate News bot message, a mysterious whale withdrew $4.29 million USDT from Aave and purchased 2,012 ETH. The whale currently holds 119,826 ETH valued at $248.98 million and maintains $4.35 million in USDT on Aave. According to Onchain Lens, this whale previously used $30.72 million USDT to acquire 1

GateNews28m ago

Citigroup Slashes Bitcoin and Ethereum 12-Month Price Targets, Citing Stalled U.S. Crypto Legislation Weighing on Upside Catalysts

Citigroup has lowered its target prices for Bitcoin and Ethereum, indicating a cautious outlook on the medium-term prospects of the crypto market. The Bitcoin target price has been reduced from $143,000 to $112,000, while Ethereum's has been lowered from $4,304 to $3,175, mainly due to slow progress in U.S. cryptocurrency legislation. Although there is still room for upward movement over the next year, the market may remain volatile in the short term, with Ethereum's valuation becoming more reliant on fundamentals.

区块客31m ago

Machi's $11.06M ETH Long Position Fully Liquidated, Total Losses Exceed $30M

Gate News bot message, Machi's 5,250 ETH long position valued at $11.06 million has been fully liquidated following a sharp market drop. His total losses have now exceeded $30.22 million, with only $158,000 remaining in his account.

GateNews34m ago

Over the past 1 hour, the entire network liquidated $183 million, with long positions accounting for over 95% of liquidations.

Gate News: On March 22nd, according to Coinglass data, the entire network experienced @1.83@ hundred million USD in contract liquidations over the past hour, with long positions liquidated at @1.74@ hundred million USD and short positions liquidated at @8.88@ million USD. By cryptocurrency type, Bitcoin contract trading liquidations reached @83.28@ million USD, and Ethereum contract trading liquidations reached @60.34@ million USD.

GateNews43m ago

ETH breaks below 2100 USDT, 24-hour decline of 2.3%

Gate News reports that on March 22, market data showed ETH falling below 2100 USDT, currently at 2099 USDT, with a 24-hour decrease of 2.3%.

GateNews46m ago

ETH drops below 2100 USDT

Gate News bot notification: According to Gate market data, ETH has broken below 2100 USDT, currently trading at 2098 USDT.

CryptoRadar54m ago
Comment
0/400
No comments